VA Claims vs. Lawsuits: Choosing the Right Path for Camp Lejeune Compensation

The discovery of contaminated water at Camp Lejeune has left a lasting legacy of illness for veterans and their families. Now, those affected have the opportunity to seek compensation for the harm they’ve endured. 

But with two main avenues for seeking justice – VA claims and lawsuits –  veterans face an important decision. Which path is right for them? 

This article discusses the key differences between VA claims and lawsuits for Camp Lejeune’s compensation. We’ll weigh the factors to consider when making this critical choice, helping veterans navigate the complexities of securing the compensation they deserve.

Overview of the Options

Camp Lejeune veterans seeking compensation for water contamination-related illnesses have two primary avenues: VA claims and lawsuits. VA claims involve filing for disability benefits and healthcare through the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). On the other hand, lawsuits entail pursuing legal action against the government under the Camp Lejeune Justice Act of 2022.

Reuters notes that victims must first file an administrative claim before proceeding to a federal lawsuit. Approximately 166,000 administrative claims have been filed with the U.S. Navy, alongside 1,500 federal lawsuits. 

Additionally,  in September 2023, an “elective option” was introduced by the U.S. government to expedite compensation for a specific subset of victims. This option offers payouts ranging from $100,000 to $550,000 based on diagnosis and duration of time spent on the base. 

However, the qualification criteria for this option remain unclear, leaving many uncertain about their eligibility.

Camp Lejeune veterans must carefully consider their choices. They must weigh the benefits and limitations of VA claims versus lawsuits in their pursuit of justice and redress.

Pros and Cons of VA Claims

VA claims offer several advantages for Camp Lejeune veterans seeking compensation for water contamination-related illnesses. These include faster processing times compared to lawsuits and no upfront costs for veterans, such as filing fees or legal representation. 

The Legal Examiner notes that under the Camp Lejeune Families Act of 2012, veterans can apply  VA claims for benefits. Enrolling in VA healthcare provides coverage for preventative care and specialist appointments. 

Additionally, veterans may qualify for disability compensation based on specific diagnoses related to water contamination, such as adult leukemia or bladder cancer. Disability payments range from 10% to 100%. Its monthly rates will vary depending on the severity of the disability and whether the veteran has dependent children.

However, VA claims also have drawbacks, including the potential for claim denials. Additionally, compensation amounts may be lower compared to lawsuits, and veterans must meet stricter requirements for service connection and disability rating. 

Despite these limitations, VA claims remain a viable option for Camp Lejeune veterans seeking financial assistance and healthcare support.

Pros and Cons of Lawsuits

Unlike VA claims, lawsuits offer more flexibility in proving the causation of illnesses. They allow veterans to present evidence and expert testimony to support their claims. Moreover, lawsuits extend to family members of veterans who were exposed to the contaminated water, expanding the scope of potential compensation.

Regarding the Camp Lejeune compensation, settlement amounts could range from $10,000 to $500,000, contingent upon the strength of the case. However, these estimates are provided by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). They offer a general framework for potential compensation but do not guarantee specific outcomes. 

The actual compensation awarded in settlements may vary based on individual circumstances and legal proceedings.

Lawsuits also entail certain drawbacks. They often involve a slower process, resulting in a longer wait for compensation compared to VA claims. Additionally, pursuing litigation requires significant upfront costs associated with legal representation, which may pose financial challenges for veterans. 

Moreover, according to TorHoerman Law, the outcome of lawsuits is uncertain, as they may not always result in a favorable judgment. Despite these limitations, lawsuits remain an important avenue for veterans seeking accountability and redress for the harms caused by the toxic exposure.

Choosing the Right Path

When deciding between VA claims and lawsuits for Camp Lejeune compensation, several factors should be carefully considered. Firstly, the severity of the illness and related medical expenses is crucial. Veterans must assess the extent of their health condition and the financial burden it imposes, as this will influence their compensation needs.

Financial need and desired compensation amount are also significant considerations. Veterans should evaluate their financial circumstances and determine the amount of compensation required to provide for their future needs adequately.

Furthermore, veterans must assess their comfort level with the legal process and potential delays associated with lawsuits. Litigation can be lengthy and complex, requiring patience and perseverance throughout the proceedings.

The availability of evidence to support a claim is another critical factor. Veterans should gather medical records, service history, and any other relevant documentation to strengthen their case and increase their chances of a favorable outcome.

Additionally, the importance of ongoing healthcare benefits cannot be overstated. Veterans must consider the value of VA healthcare benefits and weigh them against potential compensation from lawsuits.

According to, the deadline for filing administrative claims and lawsuits under the Camp Lejeune Justice Act is approaching. This emphasizes the urgency for veterans to take action. 

However, veterans should be aware that benefits received from other sources, such as the Department of Veterans Affairs, may affect their settlement or award. Additionally, attorneys may charge fees, potentially up to 25% of the award amount.

Ultimately, veterans must carefully evaluate these factors and consult with legal experts to determine the most suitable course of action for seeking compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How to win the Camp Lejeune lawsuit?

To win a Camp Lejeune lawsuit, victims must submit a claim to the Navy JAG, detailing their illnesses and damages suffered. The claim should include evidence of exposure to contaminated water, along with medical records. Comprehensive documentation strengthens the compensation case.

What are the criteria for Camp Lejeune settlement?

The criteria for Camp Lejeune settlement eligibility typically involve establishing exposure to contaminated water at the base between August 1953, and December 1987. Claimants must demonstrate a diagnosed illness linked to the toxic exposure.

What is the best way to file a claim for Camp Lejeune water contamination?

The best way to file a claim is to gather relevant documentation, such as medical records and service history. After that, the claimant needs to submit an administrative claim with the Department of Veterans Affairs. If the claim is rejected, veterans can pursue legal action through lawsuits.

In conclusion, the decision between a VA claim and a lawsuit for Camp Lejeune’s compensation is a personal one. By weighing the pros and cons of each path and seeking guidance from qualified professionals, you can determine the best course of action. 

Remember, the VA offers free assistance with filing claims, and veteran service organizations can provide valuable guidance. Don’t hesitate to leverage these resources as you navigate the path towards the compensation and recognition you deserve. The legacy of your service demands it, and your well-being depends on it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *